| Year | Champion | Conference Record | Overall Record | Championship Site |
| 2011 | Rhodes College | 5-1 | 11-7 | Memphis, Tenn. |
| 2010 | Rhodes College | 8-0 | 17-2 | Greencastle, Ind. |
| 2009 | Rhodes College |
7-1 | 13-4 | Conway, Ark. |
| 2008 | Sewanee-The University of the
South |
4-4 | 14-7 | Danville, Ky. |
| 2007 | DePauw University |
4-4 | 12-8 | Sewanee, Tenn. |
| 2006 | Rhodes College |
5-1 | 11-7 | Memphis, Tenn. |
| 2005 | Centre College |
2-4 | 11-8 | Greencastle, Ind. |
| 2004 | Rhodes College |
5-1 | 11-4 | Danville, Ky. |