Fall
- Men's Cross Country - Ben Whittemore, Trinity University
- Women's Cross Country - Megan Koch, Colorado College
- Men's Soccer - Luis Bencomo, University of St. Thomas
- Women's Soccer - Juliet Pridgen, Southwestern University
- Volleyball - Emma White, Southwestern University
Winter
- Men's Swimming & Diving - Cole Thumann, Colorado College
- Women's Swimming & Diving - Brianna Serret, Centenary College
- Men's Basketball - AJ Clark, Trinity University
- Women's Basketball - Maggie Shipley, Trinity University
Spring
- Baseball - Ezra Gore, Trinity University
- Men's Golf - Austin O'Brien, Schreiner University
- Women's Golf - Myra Truong, University of St. Thomas
- Women's Lacrosse - Susie Renehan, Colorado College
- Softball - Sydney Ouellette, Texas Lutheran University
- Men's Tennis - Steven Tibbetts, Southwestern University
- Women's Tennis - Alejandra Lopez, University of St. Thomas
- Men's Track & Field - Troy Stephenson, Texas Lutheran University
- Women's Track & Field - Megan Koch, Colorado College